• Services
    • Valuation Services
    • Investment Banking
    • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Our Team
  • Insights
    • Newsletters
    • Relevant Court Cases
    • Relevant Business Valuation Articles
    • Published Articles
    • Related Links
  • Contact
    • E-Mail
    • Map
  • Home

Fiduciary Duties and Business Valuation

October 2026

A fiduciary duty is defined in Black’s Law Dictionary as “a person holding the character of a trustee, or a character analogous to that of a trustee, in respect to the trust and confidence involved in it and the scrupulous good faith and candor which it requires.  A person having duty, created by his undertaking, to act primarily for another’s benefit in matters connected with such undertaking.  As an adjective it means of the nature of a trust; having the characteristics of a trust; analogous to a trust; relating to or founded upon a trust or confidence.  A term to refer to a person having duties involving good faith, trust, special confidence, and candor towards another.”  A fiduciary “includes such relationships as executor, administrator, trustee, and guardian.”  ABA Code of Judicial Conduct, Canon 3C.  

Fiduciary duties can affect a minority interest’s value in a business in two different ways: 1) they can change the value of the subject interest and 2) they can help determine whether a valuation discount for lack of control or lack of marketability is appropriate. 

First, they can increase or decrease the value of minority interests in a company.  Directors and, in some circumstances, controlling shareholders, may owe duties of loyalty and care to the shareholders.  Those duties can constrain self-dealing, diversion of corporate opportunities, or transactions that unfairly favor the controller.  If such conduct is prevented, stopped or remedied, the minority share’s value may be higher than otherwise.  However, the fiduciary duties may lower the value of the subject interest if those duties are breeched to the detriment of the subject interest.  Note that these duties and who owes them vary by jurisdiction and circumstances.  

They can affect valuation discounts.  A minority interest in a private company may be discounted because it lacks control or is hard to sell (minority and/or lack of marketability discounts may be applied).  But, in some statutory buyouts or appraisal proceedings, courts reject some or all of those discounts, particularly where applying them would let the company or controlling owners acquire the minority stake at an unfairly low price.  The result depends on the governing statute, the type of proceeding, and local case law. 

In a business valuation, the governing state’s law should be identified, whether it is for a sale, buyout, or appraisal, and whether the valuation standard is “fair market value” (where discounts are usually applied) or “fair value” (where discounts may not be applicable).  Those distinctions may determine whether minority or marketability discounts should be applied. 




Relevant Court Cases

  • DiCello v. DiCello, The Court of Appeals of Ohio, Eleventh Appellate District Lake County, Case No. 2026-L-0009, decided October 13, 2026

  • McReynolds v. McReynolds, The Nebraska Court of Appeals, No. A-25-813, filed October 6, 2026



Recent Business Valuation Articles

  • “Modern Approaches to the Valuation and Application of Options in the Stock Market:  Tools, Models and Behavioral Aspects,” by Iskandar Rakhmatov, posted October 23, 2026

  • “A Unified Equity Valuation Framework Under Alternative Dividend Policies,” by I-Cheng Yeh, posted September 28, 2026



Recent Engagements

  • Valuation of the common stock of an automobile dealership on a minority interest basis for gift tax reporting purposes.

  • Valuation of a member interest of a mostly real estate holding company on a minority interest basis for estate tax reporting purposes.

  • Valuation of the non-voting common stock of a niche chemical products firm on a minority interest basis for stock option issuance and purchase/sale purposes.

  • Valuation of limited partnership interests in a mostly stock investment partnership on a minority interest basis for gift tax reporting purposes.

1065 Executive Parkway, Suite 205
St. Louis, MO 63141
Ph. 314.434.3800
Fax 314.434.3809
2026 Capital Advisors, Inc.  All Rights Reserved.
"St. Louis Arch"; "Capital Advisors, Inc."; "Building"; "Conference Room"; "St. Louis Sky"; "Crane";